Jump to content
Aethon

A Deranged Christmas Dinner

Feedback  

10 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

I get off work at 0:00 st from now through Saturday and am usually home half an hour after that. I might be able to do a second dinner if you run one on a different day otherwise I will probably have to drop

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just to remind participants that the dinner will be held tomorrow at 21ST, Archive Main Hall.

Look forward to seeing you all there.

You mean I have to WALK there?  *sighs*

 

Put a jump link!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Judging was based on the following scores:

1) Conformity - Did the player(s) stick to the dinner and role theme?
2 Originality - Were they original? Or was it the same old shtick?
3) Roleplay - How good was their roleplaying?
4) Embodiment of the Role - Did the player(s) become the role(s) they played? Were you convinced?)
5) Humour - Was it fun to read? Did it make you chuckle or laugh?
6) Adaptability - How well did they react to other's RP? Did they cope well with having role swapped or missing a go?


1) 1-10 points
2) 1-10 points
3)1 -20 points
4) 1-20 points
5) 1- 5 points
6) 1-30 points

Here's how our judges scored:
[log=Judge 1]
1 = 87
Conformity - 10
Originality - 9
Roleplay - 18
Embodiment of the Role - 19
Humour - 5
Adaptability - 26

2 = 86
Conformity - 10
Originality - 8
Roleplay - 18
Embodiment of the Role - 19
Humour - 5
Adaptability - 26

3 = 88
Conformity - 10
Originality - 8
Roleplay - 19
Embodiment of the Role - 19
Humour - 5
Adaptability - 27

4 = 84
Conformity - 10
Originality - 8
Roleplay - 17
Embodiment of the Role - 19
Humour - 4
Adaptability - 26

5 = 87
Conformity - 10
Originality - 8
Roleplay - 18
Embodiment of the Role - 19
Humour - 5
Adaptability - 27

6 = 84
Conformity - 10
Originality - 8
Roleplay - 18
Embodiment of the Role - 17
Humour - 5
Adaptability - 26

7 = 87
Conformity - 10
Originality - 9
Roleplay - 18
Embodiment of the Role - 18
Humour - 5
Adaptability - 27

8 = 86
Conformity - 10
Originality - 8
Roleplay - 19
Embodiment of the Role - 18
Humour - 5
Adaptability - 26

9 = 86
Conformity - 10
Originality - 8
Roleplay - 18
Embodiment of the Role - 18
Humour - 5
Adaptability - 27 [/log]
----------------
[log=Judge 2]
1 = 86
Conformity - 10
Originality - 10
Roleplay - 19
Embodiment of the Role - 19
Humour - 3
Adaptability - 25

2 = 88
Conformity - 10
Originality - 10
Roleplay - 19
Embodiment of the Role - 19
Humour - 5
Adaptability - 25

3 = 84
Conformity - 10
Originality - 10
Roleplay - 18
Embodiment of the Role - 20
Humour - 2
Adaptability - 24

4 = 91
Conformity - 10
Originality - 10
Roleplay - 20
Embodiment of the Role - 20
Humour - 4
Adaptability - 27

5 = 93
Conformity - 10
Originality - 10
Roleplay - 20
Embodiment of the Role - 20
Humour - 4
Adaptability - 29

6 = 89
Conformity - 10
Originality - 10
Roleplay - 19
Embodiment of the Role - 20
Humour - 5
Adaptability - 25

7 = 90
Conformity - 9
Originality - 10
Roleplay - 20
Embodiment of the Role - 20
Humour - 3
Adaptability - 28

8 = 92
Conformity - 10
Originality - 10
Roleplay - 20
Embodiment of the Role - 20
Humour - 4
Adaptability - 28

9 = 81
Conformity - 10
Originality - 10
Roleplay - 17
Embodiment of the Role - 18
Humour - 2
Adaptability - 24[/log]
------------------
[log=Judge 3]
1 = 70
Conformity - 8
Originality - 7
Roleplay - 16
Embodiment of the Role - 16
Humour - 3
Adaptability - 20

2 = 67
Conformity - 9
Originality - 7
Roleplay - 18
Embodiment of the Role - 18
Humour - 5
Adaptability - 10

3 = 61
Conformity - 8
Originality - 6
Roleplay - 15
Embodiment of the Role - 14
Humour - 2
Adaptability - 16

4 = 67
Conformity - 9
Originality - 8
Roleplay - 10
Embodiment of the Role - 16
Humour - 2
Adaptability - 22

5 = 81
Conformity - 9
Originality - 7
Roleplay - 22
Embodiment of the Role - 20
Humour - 3
Adaptability - 20

6 = 79
Conformity - 9
Originality - 5
Roleplay - 22
Embodiment of the Role - 20
Humour - 3
Adaptability - 20

7 = 76
Conformity - 9
Originality - 8
Roleplay - 20
Embodiment of the Role - 16
Humour - 3
Adaptability - 20

8 = 77
Conformity - 7
Originality - 9
Roleplay - 17
Embodiment of the Role - 17
Humour - 5
Adaptability - 20

9 = 54
Conformity - 8
Originality - 4
Roleplay - 8
Embodiment of the Role - 12
Humour - 2
Adaptability - 20[/log]
--------------------

Due to the above the total scores stand at:

(1)Lintara = 243/285
(2)Jubaris = 241/285
(3)Sunfire = 233/285
(4)Ungod = 242/285
(5)Zleiphneir = 261/285
(6)Nimrodel = 252/285
(7)AmberRune = 253/285
(8)Aeoshattr = 253/285 (Winner of voting -- tie break)
(9)Miq = 221/285

1st: Zleiphneir
2nd: Aeoshattr
3rd: AmberRune

So concludes our Deranged Dinner!

Thank you to all of those that attended, to watch or partake in the festivities, and thank you to my three wonderful judges!

Winners: Congratulations! I will hand out rewards as soon as possible (probably tonight).

Non-Winners: Commiserations, but! On the bright side! You all get 1 Christmas point for taking part! Better luck next time and thank you for taking part - you were ALL great!

Judges: Thank you for your work (and some at short notice). I will be handing out a reward to each of you as a token of gratitude.

Note: Apologies for any mistakes (counting, format, etc) it's 2am and I've only my iPad to sort this all :) Let me know if there's any major mistakes and I'll endeavour to correct them.

Edited by Aethon

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Judges: Thank you for your work (and some at short notice). I will be handing out a reward to each of you as a token of gratitude.

I've been wondering if it's possible for the Judges to get a christmas point as well - after all, their involvement directly contributed to the success of the event.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I have added a feedback poll to this quest.

Please vote and leave any comments you may below. Thanks all.

-A

Edit:

I've been wondering if it's possible for the Judges to get a christmas point as well - after all, their involvement directly contributed to the success of the event.

I think that would be very nice, but is not down to me to decide. (As I know you know and weren't meaning)

I'd definitely add my vote to say throw them a point or two as well. (If needs be they can share my 5) Edited by Aethon

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Judge 3 gave a couple of scores above the limit, 26/20, 25/20, 24/20, for participants 7 and 8

 

(thus Z is first, Aeo second, Amber third now, but the question is how did he rate others, 15/20 or 15/30, or shoudl 26/20 actually be reduced to 17/20 because it's ~ 26/30, etc. )

Edited by Jubaris

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Judge 3 gave a couple of scores above the limit, 26/20, 25/20, 24/20, for participants 7 and 8

 

(thus Z is first, Aeo second, Amber third now, but the question is how did he rate others, 15/20 or 15/30, or shoudl 26/20 actually be reduced to 17/20 because it's ~ 26/30, etc. )

 

Thank you. Just got home so will sort this now.

 

My fault for not noticing.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...

  • Forum Statistics

    15,955
    Total Topics
    174,516
    Total Posts
  • Recently Browsing

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Upcoming Events

    No upcoming events found
  • Recent Event Reviews

×
×
  • Create New...